Thanks for visiting swg.c!

Why not subscribe?

My Watch List

Appointment Television
30 Rock
Big Love
Big Bang Theory
Californication
Community
Dexter
Entourage
Friday Night Lights
It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia
Mad Men
The Middle
Modern Family
Rescue Me
Robot Chicken
The Office
South Park
The Whitest Kids You Know

Homework TV
House
How I Met Your Mother
Two and a Half Men

When I Can
The Daily Show
Saturday Night Live
     
(w/DVR fast-forward)
The Simpsons

Guilty Pleasures
Glee?
Legend of the Seeker


On the Bubble
Cougar Town
Grey's Anatomy
The Riches
The United States of Tara
True Blood
Weeds

Currently Catching Up
NewsRadio (finished s4)
Curb (on s5)

To-Do List
Malcolm in the Middle
Nip/Tuck
Sons of Anarchy

Have Definitely Seen Every Single Episode
Action
Angel
Battlestar Galactica
Better Off Ted
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Carnivale
Coupling (BBC)
Dead Like Me
Deadwood
Dollhouse
Firefly
Freaks & Geeks
Lost
The Mighty Boosh (BBC)
The Loop
My Name Is Earl
Rome
Scrubs
Sex and the City
The Shield
Slings & Arrows
The Sopranos
Anything with “Star” in the title (...unless there's dancing)
Spaced (BBC)
The Tudors
West Wing
Wonder Falls
Veronica Mars



SUBSCRIBE!

Add to My Yahoo! Google Reader or Homepage Subscribe with Bloglines Subscribe in NewsGator Online Add to netvibes Add to My AOL

Most Read Posts

Top Commenters

Archives

Search


My Regular Reads:

Them’s some bad reviews…

January 26th, 2008 by screenwriterguy

Humor of Recognition ain't humor

If ever there was a sign that today’s youth is in danger of cultural brain rot, the trend in “comedy” that has included Date Movie, Epic Movie, and now Meet the Spartans is it. Fortunately, critics everywhere are jumping at the opportunity to get creative in trashing this film, and that’s got to do at least something to squash its chances. At the moment, there are 15 reviews posted at Rotten Tomatoes, giving MtS a cumulative score of 0%. I don’t think I’ve ever seen a movie that every single critic gave no right to exist.

One of my favorites is Brian Orndorf of DVDtalk.com calling it a “new low, even for these diseased buffoons,” and concluding that MtS getting made is the work of Satan. Evidently the movie goes out of its way to shower characters in vomit and other bodily fluids, and we see the first such “joke” in the first five seconds.

The problem with a movie like this getting made is that it drags the playing field down with it. The best parody of late was Scary Movie. (I haven’t seen Walk Hard yet.) Say what you will about the work of the Wayans brothers. Point out that SM has the quirk that it’s a parody largely of Scream, which is itself a parody. But SM is head-and-shoulders above these tripe films like MtS whose scripts do nothing but toss out jokeless pop culture references. Scary Movie had plenty of low-brow humor, but it also included some witty stuff, and it had this thing called a plot that a lot of your good movies like to include. I hear far too many people writing off the art form of comedy, and MtS and their ilk are part of why. I’m even offended to watch the commercials.

But I’m here to tell you that the trend might be on its way out. While tutoring this week, one of my kids asked if I had seen the trailer for MtS.

“Looks pretty stupid, doesn’t it?” he said.

Hopefully my maturing student is instead a sign that as a collective audience we’re moving past any interest we once had in the horse-semen drinking, face-in-a-fat-guy’s-butt movies of the early 21st century. Hopefully his disinterest in the film translates to more than the fact that he recently turned 14, just past the threshold for enjoying such puerility. Hopefully there aren’t millions of 12- and 13-year-olds just below him still willing to fork over the cash to make MtS a hit. Because if there are, God knows the diseased buffoons will make another.

Similar Posts:

Posted in | No Comments »

Leave a Reply